HomePoliticsHours After Trump Argument,...

Hours After Trump Argument, Cautious Reflections From Justice Kagan

“Another slow day at the office?”

It was Thursday afternoon, and Justice Elena Kagan was settling in for a public conversation at the Library of Congress. She had agreed to it long before the Supreme Court scheduled an extraordinary special session for that morning, to hear arguments over whether former President Donald J. Trump is eligible to hold office again.

The audience laughed knowingly at this opening question, from Chief Judge Jeffrey S. Sutton of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Justice Kagan said the sequence of events had an upside.

“It would be impossible to make any news today,” she said, “because everybody would be focused on the morning.”

Still, the conversation had telling moments, not least because Judge Sutton is the author of two books on the role states should play in making constitutional law. Hours earlier, Justice Kagan had, by contrast, scoffed at the idea that Colorado should be able to decide whether Mr. Trump could remain on the primary ballot there.

“The question that you have to confront,” she told a lawyer for voters challenging Mr. Trump’s eligibility, “is why a single state should decide who gets to be president of the United States,” adding: “This question of whether a former president is disqualified for insurrection to be president again is, you know — just say it — it sounds awfully national to me.”

That statement, from one of the court’s liberal members, along with skepticism from a majority of the justices, suggested that Mr. Trump was likely to prevail in the case and would be allowed to stay on the ballot around the nation unless Congress acted.

Judge Sutton, whose books bear the subtitles “States as Laboratories of Constitutional Experimentation” and “States and the Making of American Constitutional Law,” pursued the question of state power in a general way. He noted that Justice Louis D. Brandeis, whose seat Justice Kagan occupies, had been a proponent of letting states experiment with different approaches.

“Do you think there’s still a role for the states to play, or do you think it’s just ‘that was then and this is now,’ and things are really quite a bit different?” he asked.

Justice Kagan, as is her habit, turned the question around, asking what the judge thought. He responded, “It’s pretty dangerous to nationalize things too quickly, whether through legislation or court decisions.”

Asked for her own views, she said: “You know, we had an argument about this this morning. I’m a little fearful of going further.” She did allow that there is a role for states “from time to time, and then the question is what times.”

Judge Sutton, in a good-natured way, said, “You’re so evasive.” Justice Kagan responded that “maybe we should go on to a different question.”

She was more forthcoming on less topical but no less urgent subjects like respect for precedent and the value of consensus.

When the law “flip-flops” after changes in personnel, she said, “it doesn’t really look like law anymore. It kind of looks like a form of politics.”

“And I think that that’s especially important for this Supreme Court at this time,” she said. “That law should not look like a form of politics where just because the composition of the court changes a whole batch of legal rules change with it.”

She did not single out particular cases, but it was a good bet that the court’s 2022 decision overturning Roe v. Wade was among the ones on her mind.

“What was once a right is no longer a right because the court is different,” she said. “I think that that’s very damaging to the court, very damaging to society.”

She said there was a role for judicial humility, for not rejecting the considered views of earlier justices simply because a new member of the court would approach the question differently.

“It’s easy to kind of get on the court and think, ‘Well, what were they thinking? And that’s just got to be wrong. And my perspective is better. And so I’m going to do things my way.’”

The better view, she said, is that “there’s a kind of wisdom of the ages.”

“If a lot of different judges have seen something differently, you should, you know, ask yourself and then ask yourself again, are you so sure that you have it right? Maybe all those people who thought something different — maybe they were right.”

There was much to be learned, she said, from the long stretch after Justice Antonin Scalia’s death in 2016 when the court had just eight members.

“It forces compromise where you don’t think compromise is possible,” she said. “It actually felt as though it forced us to have a conversation that was useful and valuable.”

Source link

Most Popular


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More from Author

Read Now

Japan’s Cabinet approves security-clearance bill | NHK WORLD-JAPAN News

A bill to set up a security-clearance system is headed for the Japanese Diet. The...

Chris Gauthier, ‘Once Upon a Time’ and ‘Eureka’ Actor, Dies at 48

Chris Gauthier, a prolific British-born, Canadian actor known for his roles in the television shows “Once Upon a Time” and “Eureka,” died on Friday. He was 48.Tristar Appearances/Event Horizon Talent, which represented Mr. Gauthier, said in a statement that he died “after a brief illness.” His...

Draymond takes full responsibility for Warriors’ loss to Nuggets

Draymond Green was a team-worst minus-23 during the Warriors’ 119-103 loss to the Denver Nuggets on Sunday night at Chase Center, and he took responsibility for his rough performance a few hours later. On the latest “Draymond Green Show” podcast, which was recorded after Sunday's game and...

You could win a once-in-a-lifetime total solar eclipse plane ticket and hotel room in Southwest-Omni sweepstakes

Want to see the total solar eclipse on April 8 from a plane? Enter this sweepstakes for this unique opportunity. Southwest Airlines and Omni Hotels are offering two winners and their guests free air travel and hotel stays in their "Solarbration" experience for the 2024 total...

Wendy Williams’ Son Kevin Hunter Jr. Shares Her Dementia Diagnosis Is Alcohol-Induced – E! Online

Wendy Williams' family is speaking out about her dementia diagnosis. The former talk show host's son Kevin Hunter Jr. shared that doctors believe her cognitive disorder is related to her struggles with alcohol addiction. As he explained on the Feb. 25 installment of the Lifetime documentary Where is Wendy Williams?, the...

Revolutionary face unlock system from Metalenz uses Samsung’s ISOCELL Vizion sensor

Two months ago, Samsung unveiled two new ISOCELL sensors: ISOCELL Vizion 63D and ISOCELL Vizion 931. One of those sensors is now being used in a new and revolutionary 3D face unlock mechanism that Metalenz has developed. This shows the superiority of Samsung's new 3D...

Lack of Snow Prompts Cancellation of Longest Sled Dog Race in Eastern U.S.

Jonathan Hayes woke up at 5 a.m. in rural Maine to feed his 20-some dogs Monday morning, and his heart sank when he learned that the sled race they had been training for since the fall was canceled.The Can-Am Crown International Sled Dog Race, the longest...

Family Dollar pleads guilty to holding consumer products in ‘rodent-infested warehouse’

A former employee records video of rodents at a Family Dollar distribution facility. The Department of Justice announced on Monday that Family Dollar Stores LLC has pleaded guilty to holding consumer products in a "rodent-infested warehouse." The DOJ released a statement...

Netflix confirms it’s cutting off Apple billing for grandfathered subscribers

Netflix confirms to The Verge that it has begun booting longtime subscribers off their Apple iTunes billing plans, and will require them to pay Netflix directly using a credit card or debit card instead. Earlier today, The Streamable reported that Netflix had begun telling customers in...

Disney Shake-Up: Sean Bailey Leaving Studio as David Greenbaum Takes Over Live-Action Film Production

Sean Bailey (left) and David Greenbaum The Walt Disney Company via Getty Images; Michael Loccisano/Getty Images Sean Bailey, the producer turned executive who has overseen Walt Disney Studios’ live-action division for almost 15 years, is exiting the studio. In his place, David Greenbaum, who ran Searchlight Pictures with Matthew...

Palestinian Authority Prime Minister Resigns Amid Calls for Reform

Welcome back to World Brief, where we’re looking at Palestinian Authority leadership changes in the West Bank, Hungary approving Sweden’s NATO bid, and Denmark dropping its Nord Stream investigation. ...