HomeSportsHow did Max Scherzer...

How did Max Scherzer end up with Rangers? The Mets knew when to cut their losses

In late 2020, when analyzing the various traits that made Steve Cohen one of the world’s richest men as a stock trader, author Sheelah Kolhatkar hammered one home.

“He was so good at knowing when to cut your losses — because apparently that is one of the biggest areas where traders get into trouble,” Kolhatkar said. “They become really attached to certain investments and then when things change and they’re not good investments anymore, they have a really hard time making the decision to sell them. He was just very cold and focused, and he was able to make those decisions without letting his emotions get in the way.”

On Saturday night, amidst as disappointing a season as the Mets have ever had, Cohen cut his losses.

Max Scherzer is a Texas Ranger. In a deal that lingered as plausible but never felt realistic over the last month, the Mets sent Scherzer and roughly $36 million to Texas in exchange for Double-A shortstop Luisangel Acuña (younger brother of Atlanta superstar, Ronald). Acuña is a consensus top-100 prospect in the sport.

While the future of the Mets is a little brighter, the present is a whole lot more muddled.

What does this mean ahead of the MLB trade deadline?

The Mets had already announced their intention to sell with Thursday night’s trade of closer David Robertson to the Marlins. While unsurprising, the deal compelled Scherzer to want a meeting with “Mets brass” to discuss the direction of the organization.

“You trade our closer away, I’m sure a bunch of people have to have a conversation with the front office,” Scherzer said Friday night. If the Robertson trade didn’t jar some other veterans on the club, like Justin Verlander, of course, but also Pete Alonso, who is only under contract through next season, this deal will.

Less than 24 hours later, Scherzer’s a Ranger.

After initiating a conversation with GM Billy Eppler, Francisco Lindor said he received better clarification regarding what’s ahead. Lindor said he anticipated more departures from the clubhouse, but referred to the Mets’ moves as a “transition,” not a rebuild. “I am here for the long term,” Lindor added. “I am here to try to win championships. But also to be part of an amazing organization. You want to win, and you want to win now, but you also want to have stability. From my understanding, that is what I am seeing right now.”

Francisco Lindor hit a two-run home run on Saturday. (Vincent Carchietta / USA Today)

Still, the decision to go this far in selling surprised many in the clubhouse. Players heard rumblings before the game. They said to themselves, “No way.” But when some of them didn’t see Scherzer around, they took reports more seriously. During the rain delay before the 11-6 loss to the Nationals, players told Scherzer goodbye.

“Honestly, shocked,” Alonso said.

“We knew that anything could be on the table now,” Brandon Nimmo said. “We weren’t sure how far this might go, but knew that these were possibilities. I would say shocked is definitely the right word.”

Alonso said he’s briefly thought about his own future, too. But he added he feels comfortable in New York and enjoys playing for the Mets. After the Scherzer trade, players said they wondered what could be next, who else could be on the move.

“That’s a natural inclination, for sure,” Alonso said. “If a guy with a no-trade clause can get traded then anyone can. It’s a strange feeling, for sure.”

What does this mean for Justin Verlander?

It’s unclear. It’s not a certainty that Verlander will be traded, but the Scherzer deal offered a blueprint of what to expect should the Mets decide to unload their other top starter. Verlander has performed better than Scherzer and, in theory, should net a better prospect.

However, Verlander also has a no-trade clause in addition to being under contract for 2024 with a vesting option for 2025. It’s also unknown whether the Scherzer trade made Verlander feel any different about playing for the Mets.

What does this mean for 2024?

Moving Scherzer represents a different level of selling. Robertson was an impending free agent; dealing him — or Tommy Pham or Mark Canha — did not detract from the 2024 Mets.

Dealing Scherzer sure does. The Mets will pay a significant amount of the $15.2 million Scherzer is still owed this season and the $43.3 million he’s owed next year, as a major-league source confirmed to The Athletic’s Ken Rosenthal that Scherzer will not opt out of his contract. As much of a step back as Scherzer has taken this season, he will still need to be replaced in the 2024 rotation.

At the moment — and get used to hearing that given the evolving sands at our feet — the Mets are still in line to be over next season’s luxury tax with only 11 players under guaranteed contracts for next year. That includes all the dead money owed to Scherzer and others but not the arbitration raises owed to Alonso and others.

Mets 2024 Payroll














































Players shaded in blue have player options for 2024. Players shaded in orange have club options, and the money listed is the buyout on those options. Players shaded in gray are no longer with the club but will still be paid by them.

Add in estimated arbitration raises, and the figures increase to about $255 million in salary and $280 million against the luxury tax.

Their 2024 rotation consists of Verlander, Kodai Senga, José Quintana, David Peterson and Tylor Megill, with Joey Lucchesi behind them.

The free-agent starting pitching market is deeper than the position-player market this winter. Shohei Ohtani leads both, of course, but there’s also Aaron Nola, Julio Urías and potentially Yoshinobu Yamamoto as front of the rotation options — all of whom are much younger than Scherzer. Of course, they’ll require significantly longer contracts.

One constant since Cohen’s ownership: He doesn’t do things halfway, especially when it comes to money. Clearly, he wants to build a great farm system. He’s willing to absorb the cost to do so. Would he pay down contracts and continue to spend in the offseason to replace them to try to build another contender? Don’t put anything past him. He has already operated differently than any other owner.

What are the Mets getting back?

Industry sources indicated this week that the Mets were listening on their star pitchers Scherzer and Verlander in the hopes of being blown away by a prospect offer they couldn’t refuse.

Acuña fits the bill. The 21-year-old younger brother of Ronald Acuña Jr. (and son of one-time Mets minor-leaguer Ronald Sr.) entered Saturday hitting .315 with a .377 on-base percentage and .453 slugging percentage for the Double-A Frisco RoughRiders. He shares the athleticism and quick hands of his older brother, but he’ll need to refine his aggressive approach to get the most out of his game offensively. Regarding the aggressiveness, evaluators say he is getting better with his zone awareness. Acuña is in his first year on Texas’ 40-man roster.

Multiple league sources said Acuña profiles as an above-average big-league player. One evaluator said he has the ceiling of someone like Braves second baseman Ozzie Albies in part because of a speed-power combination as an up-the-middle player. Another said his swing resembles that of his older brother, though it lacks the same level of power.

In two trades now, the Mets have prioritized position-player returns and not focused on landing players who can help as soon as 2024. In the Robertson trade, they landed a pair of teenagers opening eyes in the Complex League, with ETAs closer to 2027.

(Top photo: Nick Cammett / Diamond Images via Getty Images)

Source link

Most Popular


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More from Author

Apple and Google are changing the way we listen to podcasts

This is Hot Pod, The Verge’s newsletter about podcasting and the audio...

Peloton co-founder and Chief Product Officer Tom Cortese is leaving the company

Peloton co-founder and Chief Product Officer Tom Cortese is leaving...

NFL Week 4 injury tracker: Will Jones, Watson and Montgomery play Thursday?

ESPN FantasySep 26, 2023, 04:56 PM ET6 Minute ReadESPN's Fantasy...

Read Now

Apple and Google are changing the way we listen to podcasts

This is Hot Pod, The Verge’s newsletter about podcasting and the audio industry. Sign up here for more.Hello Hot Podders, Amrita and Ariel here! Today we’re bringing you a co-bylined issue of the newsletter, mostly out of necessity. We’ve got a whole mess of news to dive into: Apple takes...

Judge Finds Trump Inflated Property Values, a Victory for New York A.G.

A New York judge ruled on Tuesday that Donald J. Trump persistently committed fraud by inflating the value of his assets, and stripped the former president of control over some of his signature New York properties.The decision by Justice Arthur F. Engoron is a major victory...

Peloton co-founder and Chief Product Officer Tom Cortese is leaving the company

Peloton co-founder and Chief Product Officer Tom Cortese is leaving the company after nearly 12 years.He'll be replaced by Silicon Valley veteran Nick Caldwell, who previously held positions at Twitter, Google and Microsoft."After nearly 12 years of pouring myself into Peloton and serving our Members, I...

NFL Week 4 injury tracker: Will Jones, Watson and Montgomery play Thursday?

ESPN FantasySep 26, 2023, 04:56 PM ET6 Minute ReadESPN's Fantasy Football Week 4 injury tracker, featuring an aggregation of injury updates for quarterbacks, running backs, wide receivers and tight ends whose teams are scheduled to play this week. Here we'll track practice reports, injury updates and...

How the Writers Deal Got Done: Inside the Room

Getty Images; Adobe Stock; THR Illustration On Saturday, Sept. 23, Disney CEO Bob Iger was in Beverly Hills, seemingly living his best life. He was at dinner with Paul McCartney and Eagles alum Joe Walsh at La Dolce Vita, an Old World Italian restaurant with long white...

Top Apple Executive Defends Favoring Google on iPhones

Apple’s top deal maker on Tuesday defended his company’s favoritism of Google on iPhones, a pivotal collaboration that has shaped the modern tech industry and is at the center of a federal antitrust trial against the search giant.Eddy Cue, Apple’s senior vice president of services, testified...

‘Unprecedented’ Secrecy in Google Trial as Tech Giants Push to Limit Disclosures

In a court filing last month, Google argued that it needed its privacy in an antitrust trial that would spotlight its dominance in online search.“Once commercially sensitive information is disclosed in open court, the resulting harm to the party’s competitive standing cannot be undone,” the internet...

How Jalen Hurts finally got the best of Todd Bowles

His stats weren’t particularly pretty. Two interceptions will do that. Still, there were some very encouraging signs from Jalen Hurts Monday night, and he didn’t hide his happiness – or maybe relief is a better word – for finally leaving Tampa with a win. It was at...

‘PAW Patrol 3’ In The Works From Paramount, Nickelodeon & Spin Master

Paramount Days before Spin Master/Paramount/Nickelodeon’s PAW Patrol: The Mighty Movie opens with a shot at No. 1 and $20M, a third theatrical movie has been announced for 2026. The long-running preschool franchise, which is celebrating its tenth anniversary, saw its first theatrical release under Paramount (and Elevation...

David McCallum, Heartthrob Spy of ‘The Man From U.N.C.L.E.,’ Dies at 90

David McCallum, the Scottish-born actor who became a surprise sensation as the enigmatic Russian spy Illya Kuryakin on “The Man From U.N.C.L.E.” in the 1960s and found television stardom again almost 40 years later on the hit series “N.C.I.S.,” died on Monday in Manhattan. He was...

CMF by Nothing launches earbuds, smartwatch, charger (Update: Availability)

TL;DR CMF by Nothing is a new sub-brand that uses the same in-house design team as mainline Nothing products. The first three devices from this sub-brand are earbuds, a smartwatch, and a GaN charger. The products are incredibly inexpensive and will come to the UK at first. India is...

Warriors newcomer Chris Paul can win the room with 11-word declaration

The wisest and classiest move Chris Paul can make in the coming days is to extinguish the fire that started with his cryptic response in his first meeting with reporters assigned to the Warriors. Sometime before next Monday, when Paul and his new teammates gather for media...