HomeEntertainmentHow the Strikes Could...

How the Strikes Could Impact Lavish Hollywood CEO Pay

As Hollywood actors and writers strike together for the first time in more than half a century, executive pay is in the spotlight. Talent are posting residuals checks barely worth the postage it cost to mail them alongside captions criticizing Hollywood execs’ 8-figure pay packages.

SAG-AFTRA and the Writers Guild of America didn’t strike because of C-suite pay, of course, but the optics of such disparity are fueling the flames.

“What’s happening right now in Hollywood is a microcosm for what’s happening across America,” says Robert Reich, former U.S. Secretary of Labor and co-founder of the Economic Policy Institute. CEOs of major corporations often earn hundreds of times the salary of the typical worker, he notes, and some entertainment companies have ratios even more jarring.

“Is this fair? Fairness is in the eyes of the beholder, obviously, but it certainly doesn’t feel it and it does rub a lot of people the wrong way,” says Reich. “It seems like the game is rigged against average working people and in favor of people at the top. You have a lot of anger, a lot of frustration, and you ultimately have work stoppages and strikes.”

When the writers and actors struck in 1960, top executives made a mere fraction of what they do today and only about 20 times that of the typical worker. According to a 2022 study from EPI, CEO pay increased 1,460 percent from 1978 to 2021.

In those intervening years, Reich notes, there was an increase in executive pay coming in the form of stocks and stock options. That created an incentive for CEOs to increase the price of shares through things like stock buybacks, which not only made the executives money but also made them seem more valuable to the business.

“If they have a record of being able to push stock prices up, that makes them somebody who their directors want to pay more,” says Reich. “No set of directors in any corporation is going to want to tell shareholders that they held back and didn’t get the best top executive they could.”

Steven Kaplan, a professor at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business notes that now the median salary for CEOs at S&P 500 companies is about $15 million. “People have complained about [those salaries] for decades, and it doesn’t change because that’s the market,” Kaplan says. “They’re very rare, it’s a very hard job and that’s what they get paid. The entertainment CEOs are paid, in many cases, a lot more than that.”

Source: SEC.gov

In 2022, total compensation for the highest paid Hollywood execs was more than $240 million — and nearly $314 million if you add in NBCUniversal parent Comcast. The median compensation among those featured on THR‘s CEO scorecard in June was $32 million. (Note: The figures in this paragraph do not include Endeavor CEO Ari Emanuel, as the agencies are neutral parties to the strike.)

“Let’s say you’re paying somebody $20 million, which is not unusual,” Kaplan posits, “Let’s say a company is worth $100 billion dollars, and a good CEO is going to make that company worth 10 or 20 percent more. If the person is going to increase the value of your company by $20 billion, giving that person $20 million is a bargain.”

In a rare move, after the WGA strike was called Netflix shareholders rejected the pay packages for top executives at the company.

This came even after the streamer’s compensation committee reworked the packages to increase the proportion of stock options and lower annual salary. For 2023, executive chairman Reed Hastings, co-CEO Ted Sarandos, co-CEO Greg Peters must each take at least half of their pay in the form of stock, and the co-CEOs’ salary is capped at $3 million with the remaining balance coming in the form of those target bonuses.

Under the proposed packages, those three plus CFO Spencer Neumann, chief legal officer David Hyman and chief communications officer Rachel Whetstone would bring in a combined $109 million in total compensation — with a cumulative $23.2 million in salary and $54.6 million in stock options (plus a combined $31.3 million in target bonuses for Sarandos and Peters).

In June, the streamer’s executive compensation packages failed by a wide margin — with more than 71 percent voting no. It remains to be seen how Netflix’s board of directors will respond to the feedback.

“That’s the shareholders telling the board ‘We think you’re overpaying these folks,’” says Kaplan. “Usually what happens when you get a negative shareholder vote like that is the next year the board does something, takes some action. Occasionally they ignore it. Although, then the risk is that someone will run a proxy fight.”

These Say on Pay votes were established in 2011 by the SEC after the passage of the Dodd-Frank Act and require most public companies to give shareholders periodic input on the pay of the CEO, CFO and at least three other highly compensated executives. How often the votes are taken varies by company, but the minimum is every three years. They’re advisory only — meaning the company has no obligation to change their pay structure if shareholders vote against the plans — but typically a no vote will spark some kind of action.

“If the shareholders approved it, that’s the acid test,” says Kaplan. “The shareholders are saying we’re getting value for this. If the shareholders vote against it, then you have to think maybe you should make a change.”

Comcast shareholders in June overwhelmingly supported the company’s executive compensation packages, but earlier this spring Warner Bros. Discovery’s Say on Pay vote eked out an approval with about 50.8 percent.

In addition to the scrutiny on executive compensation, the strikes are also correcting some misconceptions about what life in Hollywood looks like for most people.

“Most of America thinks that writers and actors in Hollywood are all famous and bathed in money and glory,” Reich says. “But the typical writer is one of many people trying to get into the business of writing, and therefore is competing like mad with other writers — and soon to be competing with artificial intelligence — and that’s pushing down the writers’ salaries. In fact, there’s been something like a 23 percent drop over the decade. At the same time, most actors are not stars.”

According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics July 18 report, the median U.S. worker’s weekly pay is $1,100 — the equivalent of $57,200 per year or $31.43 per hour. (The hourly rate was calculated using the BLS minimum of 35 hours per week for full-time employment, though the average private sector employee works about 34.4 hours as of June 2023.)

As of May 2022, the BLS estimated the median actor pay was $17.94 per hour. According to SAG-AFTRA members who have spoken out amid the strike, many working actors struggle to make the minimum of $26,470 per year that’s required to qualify for the union’s health plan.

“A lot of people are not in a position to live without money coming in,” says Reich. “People tend to lose track of the fact that strikes are hard on workers. If you are only earning $26,000 a year and you go on strike, how are you going to continue to live? The typical worker in America is living paycheck to paycheck, and that’s even truer of workers in in Los Angeles.”

It’s difficult to truly compare the incomes of working writers and actors with studio executives because a lot of the information isn’t public, but there is some data that highlights the disparity between top brass and the general workforce at entertainment and tech companies.

Companies are required to disclose each year to the FTC the ratio of CEO compensation to the median employee pay. The lowest ratio for 2022 was Amazon’s Andy Jassy — who in 2021 with his one-time stock award worth about $212 million had the highest ratio in the S&P 500 at 6,474:1 — while Apple’s Tim Cook saw an almost 9-figure pay package and more than double the ratio of former Disney CEO Bob Chapek.

When split between two co-CEOs Netflix’s ratio is below average, but when you consider that the total CEO compensation packages for 2022 were about $101.4 million that puts the streamer at 464:10, which is second only to Apple.

Most Hollywood companies won’t have to face a Say on Pay vote until early next year, and it remains to be seen how heavily the strikes and salary criticism will weigh on shareholders or how much that will ultimately matter.

“[Most] shareholders don’t really have very much power. What can the typical shareholder do? At most just sell the share,” says Reich. “The real power is in the institutional shareholders, the big pension funds that dominate Wall Street.”

So far the strikes haven’t spooked Wall Street too much, with most entertainment and media shares holding steady or seeing low single-digit drops, but Kaplan says eventually they will have an impact.

“The strike, if it goes on for long, hurts the company,” he says. “When the company value goes down, the shareholders are not happy — and the CEO’s shares also go down.”

Kaplan continues, “We don’t know how it’s going to turn out. We have the actors saying, ‘Look, we’re worth more than you’re willing to pay us.’ And the CEOs are saying, ‘No, you’re not.’ We’re going to see who’s right. That’s what you get in a market system.”

“Economics is not just supply and demand,” adds Reich. “This is all about power. These giant companies have extraordinary power by virtue of their size. On the other hand, individual workers, individual actors and individual writers have extraordinarily little power. If they join together in unions, and if the unions join together as the actors and the writers have done for the first time since the 1960s, that is potentially a lot of power that can change the rules of the game.”

Carlos Alvarez/Getty Images, Taylor Hill/WireImage, Courtesy of Comcast, Santiago Felipe/Getty Images, Rodin Eckenroth/GA/The Hollywood Reporter via Getty Images, Michael Tullberg/Getty Images, Emma McIntyre/Getty Images for Netflix, Laurent Viteur/Getty Images, Amy Sussman/Getty Images, Taylor Hill/Getty Images, Michael Buckner/Variety via Getty Images, Steve Granitz/FilmMagic.

Source link

Most Popular


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More from Author

FTC sues Texas anesthesiology provider to bust monopoly

The Federal Trade Commission sued the largest anesthesiology provider in...

Sources: Cowboys star CB Diggs has torn ACL

Todd ArcherESPN Staff WriterSep 21, 2023, 03:56 PM ET3 Minute...

CEOs Return to WGA Talks as Some Movement Seen Toward a Deal

AFP via Getty Images Four Hollywood CEOs returned to the bargaining...

Warzone Season 6 brings back fan-favorite Zombie game mode – Dexerto

Ryan Lemay  ❘   Published: 2023-09-21T18:46:38  ❘   Updated: 2023-09-21T18:46:52 Activision...

Read Now

FTC sues Texas anesthesiology provider to bust monopoly

The Federal Trade Commission sued the largest anesthesiology provider in Texas, claiming the company has wielded monopoly power to drive up prices for patients and boost its profits.The FTC asked a federal judge in Houston, Texas, to break up U.S. Anesthesia Partners alleged monopoly power and...

Sources: Cowboys star CB Diggs has torn ACL

Todd ArcherESPN Staff WriterSep 21, 2023, 03:56 PM ET3 Minute ReadFRISCO, Texas -- Dallas Cowboys star cornerback Trevon Diggs has a torn ACL in his left knee, sources told ESPN's Adam Schefter.Diggs suffered the injury Thursday during a one-on-one drill in practice and was briefly spotted...

CEOs Return to WGA Talks as Some Movement Seen Toward a Deal

AFP via Getty Images Four Hollywood CEOs returned to the bargaining table Thursday for a second day of talks with the Writers Guild of America, as the industry looked for signs of progress toward a deal that would end the 143-day strike. Sources said the studios made moves...

Warzone Season 6 brings back fan-favorite Zombie game mode – Dexerto

Ryan Lemay  ❘   Published: 2023-09-21T18:46:38  ❘   Updated: 2023-09-21T18:46:52 Activision unveiled the Modern Warfare 2 and Warzone Season 6 roadmap, highlighted by the return of Zombie Royale. Modern Warfare 2 and Warzone Season 6: The Haunting embraces a Halloween theme. Fittingly, the update adds new...

Trump urges government shutdown in unlikely bid to ‘defund’ his criminal prosecutions

Former U.S. President and Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks during a 2024 presidential campaign rally in Dubuque, Iowa, U.S. September 20, 2023. REUTERS/Scott Morgan/File Photo Acquire Licensing RightsSept 21 (Reuters) - Former President Donald Trump has urged fellow Republicans in Congress to shut...

For Tesla and Musk, Auto Strike Carries Benefits and Risks

The United Automobile Workers strike against the Michigan automakers would seem to be nothing but good news for Tesla, the electric vehicle maker that has upended the industry and stolen customers from Ford Motor, General Motors and Stellantis, which owns Jeep and Ram.Unencumbered by an activist...

Lengthy lane closure coming to U.S. 41 southbound Twin Bridge

Chuck Stinnett  |  Special to the Courier & PressDriving from Evansville to Henderson could be a little tricky over the next couple of months.The southbound U.S. 41 Twin Bridge will be down to one lane from this Monday (Sept. 25) through Nov. 18 for a special extended...

Russell Brand ‘exposed himself to woman then laughed about it on BBC radio’

Resurfaced footage shows moment Katy Perry found out Russell Brand dumped herSign up to our free IndyArts newsletter for all the latest entertainment news and reviewsSign up to our free IndyArts newsletter A woman has alleged Russell Brand exposed himself to her and then laughed about it...

49ers GM Lynch recalls play Isaiah Oliver officially ‘became a Niner’

When the 49ers' defense was almost unrecognizable in the first half of their clash with the Los Angeles Rams on Sunday, cornerback Isaiah Oliver provided a much-needed boost to rejuvenate the typically dominant unit in the third quarter. His dominant showing earned him the team's defensive player...

Apple Releases iOS 17.0.1 and iPadOS 17.0.1 With Bug Fixes, Plus iOS 17.0.2 for iPhone 15 Models

Thursday September 21, 2023 10:28 am PDT by Juli CloverApple today released iOS 17.0.1 and iPadOS 17.0.1 updates for the iPhone and the iPad, adding bug fixes to the new software. The iOS 17.0.1 and iPadOS 17.0.1 updates come just a few days after Apple launched...


United States Secretary of State Antony Blinken has lauded Kenya’s contribution to peace and stability in the Horn of Africa and across the world. Mr Blinken said Kenya, under President William Ruto, has established itself as a champion of regional peace and security. Secretary Blinken commended Kenya for...

Dolph Ziggler, Elias, Top Dolla and WWE Stars Released from Contracts After Merger

Jim Spellman/Getty ImagesSeveral WWE Superstars were reportedly released from their contracts Thursday following WWE's merger with UFC into TKO Group Holdings last week.According to Fightful's Sean Ross Sapp, WWE cut ties with Dolph Ziggler, Elias, Shelton Benjamin, Rick Boogs, Emma, Riddick Moss, Top Dolla and Aliyah....