HomeBusinessJudge clears way for...

Judge clears way for DOJ’s antitrust case against Google to go to trial

SAN FRANCISCO — A federal judge said the Department of Justice’s landmark case alleging Google’s dominance over the online search business is anti-competitive can go ahead, throwing out some of the government’s claims but ruling that a trial is still necessary.

Google had asked for the judge to make a ruling before the trial, which is scheduled for September. Some of the government’s claims, including those put together by a consortium of state attorneys general that argued the way Google designed its search engine page was unfairly harming competitors like Yelp, were dismissed.

But D.C. District Court Judge Amit Mehta said the allegations that Google’s overall business practices constitute a monopoly that violates the 1890 Sherman Antitrust Act still deserve a trial.

“This is a significant victory for Google, knocking out several claims and narrowing the range of activities at issue for trial,” said David Olson, an associate professor and antitrust expert at Boston College’s law school. “Having said that, the strongest claims against Google remain, so Google still remains at risk of a significant antitrust ruling against it.”

The trial will be a major test for Google and the massive business empire it has assembled over the past two decades. The company is still the dominant portal to the internet, exercising immense power over what people see online. The case is the culmination of one of many antitrust investigations launched against Google and other Big Tech companies over the last several years. The eventual ruling will also be seen as a test for the U.S. government’s more aggressive posture on antitrust.

“People have more ways than ever to access information, and they choose to use Google because it’s helpful. We look forward to showing at trial that promoting and distributing our services is both legal and pro-competitive,” said Kent Walker, Google’s president of global affairs and chief legal officer.

The DOJ did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Over the past several years, a new, more aggressive approach to antitrust has become popular among lawmakers and regulators in the United States. Officials like Federal Trade Commission Chair Lina Khan have bucked decades of antitrust policy more deferential to corporations and focused on consumer harm rather than fighting consolidation in general.

But the new crop of antitrust crusaders has run up against the U.S. court system, where some judges have been skeptical of the new approach. In July, a judge dealt a significant blow to the government’s attempts to slow consolidation when it ruled Microsoft could go ahead with its acquisition of video game giant Activision. The FTC is appealing the decision.

In the Friday ruling, the judge in the Google case rejected the government’s argument that Google’s illegal dominance was built on a set of behaviors that on their own might not be illegal, Olson said. “Instead, Judge Mehta ruled that the plaintiffs must accuse and prove each separate behavior as anticompetitive.”

The trial will begin in the midst of a boom in generative AI — a wave of new technology that has been pushed by Google’s competitors and has thrown the company onto its back foot. Google executives have already begun arguing that the rise of AI companies like OpenAI shows that the tech world is still competitive and that the company doesn’t have an unfair grip on who wins and who loses, as some antitrust experts and the company’s competitors have argued.

Source link

Most Popular


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More from Author

Read Now

Pokémon Trading Card Game Pocket Announced, Brings the TCG to Mobile in 2024 – IGN

Pokémon Trading Card Game Pocket is a new mobile game that brings the popular Pokémon Trading Card Game into the digital world via iOS and Android.During today's Pokémon Presents showcase, we saw players swipe to open virtual packs of Pokémon trading cards, which could then be...

Stocks are little changed Tuesday as traders assess fresh earnings and new data: Live updates

35 Mins AgoStocks open flat TuesdayU.S. stocks started Tuesday's trading session little changed.The Dow Jones Industrial Average slipped 42 points, or 0.1%.The S&P 500 and Nasdaq Composite inched up 0.1% and 0.2%, respectively. — Hakyung Kim43 Mins AgoHome prices posted a slightly higher than expected increase...

Disney World sued after NYU doctor tragically dies from allergic reaction to restaurant meal

A doctor from New York University allegedly died after having dinner at Raglan Road Irish Pub and Restaurant at Disney Springs. Her heartbroken husband has now filed a 19-page lawsuit against the park, blaming its incompetent employees. ...

NFL Draft’s quiet star was built for this moment — and he’s rising up draft boards

If you stand 10 feet from Quinyon Mitchell while he’s in a full sprint, you can actually hear how fast he is. If you stand 10 feet away and ask him a question, you might not hear his reply.A cornerback of world-class speed, Mitchell plays football...

Israel-Gaza war live: Israel-Hezbollah escalation puts ceasefire at risk, UN says

Israel-Hezbollah escalation puts efforts to find solution at risk, UN saysThe UN Interim Force in Lebanon said the recent escalation between Israel and Hezbollah has the potential to jeopardise efforts to find a political solution to the conflict."Over the past days we have seen a concerning...

Qatar ‘optimistic’ about ongoing Israel-Gaza ceasefire talks

Qatar 'optimistic' about ongoing Israel-Gaza ceasefire talks  Al Jazeera EnglishIsraeli military presents plan to war cabinet for evacuating Gaza’s population from ‘fighting areas’  CNNNetanyahu says hostage deal will delay Rafah operation  Axios Source link

Depardieu faces new allegation of sexual assault – BBC News

1 hour agoImage source, Getty ImagesFrench actor Gérard Depardieu is facing a new allegation of sexual assault, this time from a set designer.The complainant, Amélie, 53, alleges that Depardieu grabbed her and touched her breasts in 2021.The alleged assault is claimed to have occurred on the...

13-year-old tests Archimedes’ death ray for science fair project

Angle down icon An icon in the shape of an angle pointing down. Bettmann via Getty Images Scientists and historians have pointed out that Archimedes had other weapons at his...

Power Rankings: Cognizant Classic in The Palm Beaches – PGA TOUR

Power Rankings: Cognizant Classic in The Palm Beaches - PGA TOUR  PGA TOUR2024 Cognizant Classic odds, picks, Fantasy golf power rankings: PGA Tour predictions and best bets for this week's event from golf expert  SportsLineCognizant Classic 2024 DFS picks: This egregiously mispriced golfer is a slam-dunk play  GolfDigest.comCognizant Classic...

Taylor Swift’s Rep Speaks Out After Dad Scott Swift Allegedly Assaults Paparazzo – E! Online

An Australian paparazzo allegedly has bad blood with Taylor Swift's dad. The singer's rep spoke out after Scott Swift allegedly attacked a photographer in Sydney on Feb. 27 following Taylor's Eras Tour concerts down under, according to TMZ. In response to the report, a spokesperson for Taylor told E! News that two...

Malaysia Under-19 vs Bahrain Under-19 Live Score: Malaysia Under-19 beat Bahrain Under-19 by 3 wickets

Welcome to the live coverage of Match 6 of ICC U19 Men's CWC Division 2 Asia Qualifier, 2024 Malaysia Under-19 vs Bahrain Under-19 Match Details Match 6 of ICC U19 Men's CWC Division 2 Asia Qualifier, 2024 between Malaysia Under-19 and Bahrain Under-19...