HomeBusinessJudge Narrows Scope of...

Judge Narrows Scope of Coming Trial Over Google Monopoly Claims

A federal judge said this week that the Justice Department and a group of states could not move forward with some claims in antitrust complaints against Google, narrowing the scope of what is set to be the most significant federal monopoly trial against a tech giant in decades.

In the decision, which was unsealed on Friday, Judge Amit P. Mehta of U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia dismissed four claims in the lawsuits and allowed government lawyers to move forward with three.

Judge Mehta wrote that a trial was warranted to assess whether Google’s exclusivity deals for web browsers and preloading its services on Android devices illegally helped the internet company maintain a monopoly. But he said the government had not “demonstrated the requisite anticompetitive effect” to prove that Google broke the law in other ways, such as by boosting its own products in search results over those of specialized sites, like Amazon and Yelp.

The decision sets the stage for the first major tech monopoly trial since the federal government took Microsoft to court in the 1990s, amid a renewed backlash over the power of tech giants. In recent years, American regulators have filed lawsuits and tried to block the acquisitions of companies such as Google, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft and Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram, as they have grown in reach and size.

Some efforts by regulators to challenge the tech giants have faltered. Twice this year, federal judges have declined to grant Federal Trade Commission requests to stop tech deals, allowing Meta to close the purchase of a virtual reality start-up and clearing the way for Microsoft’s blockbuster acquisition of the video game publisher Activision Blizzard.

But the Google trial, which is scheduled to begin on Sept. 12, stands out as the most direct government attempt in years to confront one of the world’s biggest tech companies about longtime business practices. The trial is expected to last almost 10 weeks and to scrutinize not only how Google conducts business but its relationships with other major companies, such as Apple and Samsung, which have largely been shrouded in secrecy.

Bill Baer, a former Justice Department antitrust official, said the cases were as significant as the landmark litigation against Microsoft.

The outcome “will set an important precedent about whether these dominant tech platforms are engaging in behavior that limits competition and disadvantages consumers,” he said.

Kent Walker, Google’s president of global affairs, said in a statement on Friday that the company appreciated Judge Mehta’s “careful consideration and decision to dismiss claims regarding the design of Google Search.”

The Justice Department did not respond to a request for comment.

The department filed an antitrust case against Google under President Donald J. Trump in 2020. It argues that the Silicon Valley company exploits its power over online search and the ads that appear in search results. The lawsuit was ultimately combined for trial with a separate case about Google search that was filed that same year by the attorneys general of 35 states, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico and Guam.

The Justice Department has separately filed another antitrust case against Google, focused on the company’s software for placing ads across the web, which is headed to trial as soon as next year.

In his ruling, Judge Mehta allowed the core of the Justice Department’s case to stand. But he dismissed three of the agency’s claims regarding Google’s management of the Android operating system, its relationships to phone makers that use Android and its Google Assistant service. He also threw out a central claim brought by the states, which accused Google of providing top billing in its search results to its own products.

Judge Mehta acknowledged in his opinion that Google was extremely popular and noted the bar that government lawyers must clear to prove that it had broken antitrust rules.

It is not illegal for Google to have a monopoly alone, he wrote, adding, “A company with monopoly power acts unlawfully only when its conduct stifles competition.”

At trial, both sides are set to argue over whether the company’s multibillion-dollar agreements to be the default search engine on various devices and browsers are anticompetitive, which could have significant consequences for its core business. Google’s search engine collected $162 billion in advertising revenue last year.

Google has argued that these pacts with companies like Apple and Samsung are simple distribution deals that are common in business, and that the government has tried to penalize Google because of its popularity.

The agreements have been a linchpin in Google’s efforts to be easily accessible to large audiences. The company retains an estimated 94 percent of search engine traffic on mobile devices, according to Similarweb, a data analysis firm.

Source link

Most Popular


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More from Author

Read Now

Microsoft CEO says unfair practices by Google led to its dominance as a search engine

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella says unfair tactics used by Google led to its dominance as a search engine, tactics that in turn have thwarted his company’s rival program, BingBy SUMAN NAISHADHAM Associated PressOctober 2, 2023, 3:30 PM ET• 4 min readWASHINGTON -- Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella...

Kate Middleton shows off her skills while William doles out hugs on visit to Cardiff to mark Black History Month

The Prince and Princess of Wales took each other on in a game of table tennis this afternoon as they met with Windrush elders in Cardiff.Dressed in a £549 navy pinstripe jacket from Holland Cooper and matching wide-leg navy trousers, Kate, 41, teamed up with a...

Sam Bankman-Fried heads for trial on charges of stealing billions from FTX users

Indicted FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried leaves the United States Courthouse in New York City, U.S., July 26, 2023. REUTERS/Amr Alfiky/File Photo Acquire Licensing RightsNEW YORK, Oct 3 (Reuters) - Sam Bankman-Fried is set to go on trial on charges of stealing billions of dollars from customers...

Liverpool vs PGMOL: What do the club hope to achieve after VAR row?

Almost 72 hours after Liverpool’s contentious defeat to Tottenham Hotspur, the fallout rumbles on. A review is underway into the errors that led to Luis Diaz’s goal being disallowed for offside, with VAR Darren England and assistant VAR Dan Cook, who failed to overturn the on-field decision...

Devon Witherspoon: Seahawks knew Daniel Jones likes to stare down his first target

Seahawks cornerback Devon Witherspoon had a sensational game on Monday...

Tori Spelling’s “Oldest Babies” Are All Grown Up in High School Homecoming Photo – E! Online

Forget Donna Martin: Tori Spelling is about to have a few high school graduates on her hands very soon. The Beverly Hills, 90210 alum proved that her two "oldest babies" are all grown up by sharing a photo of daughter Stella, 15, and son Liam, 16, heading to their...

Mudavadi delivers Ruto’s message to President Ndayishimiye

Prime Cabinet Secretary Musalia Mudavadi on Monday delivered President William Ruto's message to his Burundi counterpart, President Evariste Ndayishimiye.Mudavadi delivered the message during his one-day official visit to Bujumbura, Burundi.In the meeting with President Ndayishimiye, the two leaders held talks to strengthen the bilateral ties...

How Trump Turned an Oval Office Fantasy Into G.O.P. Doctrine

The first time Donald Trump talked privately about shooting missiles into Mexico to take out drug labs, as far as his former aides can recall, was in early 2020.And the first time those comments became public was when his second defense secretary, Mark T. Esper, wrote...

Rouble recovers slightly after slide past 100 vs dollar

A view shows a Russian one rouble coin in front of a screen displaying the Spasskaya tower of the Moscow Kremlin in this illustration picture taken August 22, 2023. REUTERS/Maxim Shemetov/Illustration/File photo Acquire Licensing RightsOct 3 (Reuters) - The Russian rouble weakened past the symbolic...