HomePoliticsMore Israeli ministers must...

More Israeli ministers must commit to obeying the High Court – editorial

One of the front-page headlines in Monday’s edition of this newspaper was very problematic: “Only three gov’t ministers pledge to respect court ruling.”

The headline was problematic not because there was anything technically or grammatically wrong with it; the headline faithfully summed up the gist of the story.

Instead, the concern lies with the news itself: out of the 33 ministers comprising this coalition’s inflated government, only three would commit publicly to following the High Court of Justice’s decision – come what may – in the hearing that begins Tuesday on the law to limit the reasonableness standard.

Even in these unhinged times when red lines are regularly crossed – when a former Mossad head gives ammunition to every anti-Israel activist in the world by saying outrageously that Israel is enacting “apartheid” in the West Bank, and when a haredi (ultra-Orthodox) MK slanders Zionism and charges that Zionists thwarted efforts to rescue Jews during the Holocaust (a horrific falsehood) – it remains astounding that so few ministers are willing to declare their intention to abide by the court’s decision on this matter.

Even more dismaying is that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is not among those three.

PRIME MINISTER Benjamin Netanyahu and National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir are among cabinet ministers attending a state budget meeting, earlier this year. (credit: YONATAN SINDEL/FLASH90)

Netanyahu offers no guarantees

Netanyahu, who should be forcefully speaking out against ministers and MKs saying they will not listen to the court if its ruling goes against their wishes, has pointedly refused to say that he would obey the court if it strikes down this amendment to a basic law. Instead, he has suggested that if the court interferes with a basic law, it would exceed its authority.

According to this argument, it would not be the government violating the rules of the game if it disregarded a court decision in this matter; rather, it would be the court overstepping its boundaries.

But this is faulty reasoning.

Every game, including the game of governance, has rules. Some countries are lucky enough to have a constitution that sets the basic rules; others – like Israel – are less fortunate. Rather, the rules in those countries develop organically over time.

While it is crystal clear in the rules that govern Israel that everyone must obey the law, meaning everyone must listen to the court, there is no such clarity regarding whether the court can challenge a basic law.

This is a somewhat murky area. Just because the court has never done this before does not mean it is forbidden. In fact, if the court were prevented from striking down basic laws or amendments to them, then any government could pass any law it desired as a basic law, thereby precluding any judicial review. That situation, obviously, is untenable.Equally untenable is a government that does not listen to the court.

Not only is it untenable, it opens the door to anarchy, to a situation described in the Book of Judges where “everyone did what was right in his own eyes.” If the government does not heed the court’s decision, why should anyone else?

Democracy rests on several pillars, and one of its central ones is the supremacy of the law. If government ministers do not recognize the supremacy of the law, then there are no rules to the game, and if there are no rules to the game, then eventually, there may be no game at all.

Recognizing the law’s supremacy means doing so even when the law goes against you. Former prime minister Menachem Begin famously gave voice to this sentiment in 1979 when, following a Supreme Court decision that went against settlement at the time in Elon Moreh – something he believed in with every fiber of his being – he purportedly said, “there are judges in Jerusalem.” By this, he meant that there are justices in Jerusalem and that their decisions must be respected.

During a heated cabinet meeting after the court’s ruling, some members of Begin’s cabinet demanded that the government disregard the decision. Begin, however, adamantly disagreed, reportedly declaring, “The courts in Israel have made their decision, and the government is obligated to honor and carry out whatever they decided.”What was so clear for Begin should be equally clear to Netanyahu; what was true then is equally true today.

Source link

Most Popular


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More from Author

Read Now

The New York Film Festival opens with the industry in limbo

Comment on this storyCommentNEW YORK — The New York Film Festival got off to a stylish start Friday night with a party at Central Park’s famed Tavern on the Green — or as stylish as you can get when none of the striking actors in this...

Live updates from Week 5 of college football

No. 6 Penn State 10, Northwestern 10 Early turnovers were always apart of Northwestern’s upset formula against top-10 Penn State, but even the most optimistic Wildcat fans likely couldn’t imagine forcing a turnover on the very first play.  After fielding the opening kickoff on a triple hop, Penn...

Apple Says iPhone 15 Pro’s Titanium Frame Does Not Contribute to Overheating Issue

Apple today said it plans to release an iOS 17 software update with a bug fix for the iPhone 15 Pro and iPhone 15 Pro Max overheating issue, and the company has since shared additional details about the matter with MacRumors. Importantly, Apple said the issue is...

Beyonce in Final Talks to Release ‘Renaissance’ Concert Film Through AMC Theatres Following Taylor Swift Deal (EXCLUSIVE)

Mason Poole A film based on Beyonce‘s smash hit Renaissance World Tour is in advanced talks to distribute directly to AMC Theatres, sources with knowledge of the project told Variety. Mega-agency CAA held preliminary talks with major studios and streamers two weeks ago, another source added, urging...

These are the top 4 Club stocks — and the bottom 4 — during the third quarter

September, historically the worst month of the year for stocks, once again brought pain to Wall Street, sending the market lower for the third quarter. A steep rise in Treasury yields and oil prices, combined with fears that the Federal Reserve would keep interest rates "higher...

Apple Says iPhone 15 Pro Overheating Due to iOS 17 Bug, Not Hardware Design

Widespread complaints about overheating of the new iPhone 15 Pro and Pro Max can be traced to several factors, including a software bug in iOS 17, Apple told CNET on Saturday. The company said the new phones' titanium frame and aluminum substructure aren't contributing to the issue, and that...

Giants LT Thomas out; Saquon a game-time call

Jordan RaananESPN Staff WriterSep 30, 2023, 11:57 AM ET2 Minute ReadEAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. -- The New York Giants could be extremely short-handed Monday night with left tackle Andrew Thomas being ruled out and running back Saquon Barkley expected to be a game-day decision, according to coach...

Amy Schneider, historic ‘Jeopardy!’ champ, is more than a trivia buff

Comment on this storyCommentThe past two years have been a whirlwind for Amy Schneider. In late 2021, the trivia buff became a household name when she appeared on “Jeopardy!” and rattled off a remarkable 40-game winning streak — the second highest in the show’s history.Her success...

Tory MPs demand Cabinet minister position for the North and 500,000 new homes

For free real time breaking news alerts sent straight to your inbox sign up to our breaking news emailsSign up to our free breaking news emailsA group of Conservative MPs representing the North of England has set out a manifesto calling for a dedicated Cabinet minister...

‘Any of us can foster’: New short film encourages more people in Wakefield to become foster carers

Rachel said: “We hope that this will mean that the film and its messaging will appeal to as wider audience as possible and encourage people to foster for their local authority.The film looks at three very different people who all show some of the attributes needed...