HomePoliticsTOC editor does not...

TOC editor does not have to serve more jail time for defaming Cabinet members: High Court

SINGAPORE – The High Court ruled on Friday that Terry Xu, the chief editor of The Online Citizen (TOC), does not have to serve any more jail time for defaming Cabinet members on top of the three-week term he has already completed.

Xu was originally sentenced to three weeks’ jail by a district court in April 2022 after he was convicted of a criminal defamation charge.

An unusual situation arose because Xu, who has since relocated to Taiwan, chose to serve the jail term, even as he pursued an appeal.

In May 2023, the High Court allowed his appeal and reduced his sentence to a fine of $8,000, which carried a two-week default jail term in lieu of payment.

Xu did not want to pay the fine. His lawyers, Mr Choo Zheng Xi and Ms Carol Yuen, argued that considering the time he has already served, he should be deemed to have served the default term in lieu of paying the fine.

But the prosecution argued that this was legally not allowed, and that he must serve the two-week default term despite having previously served the three-week prison term.

On Friday, Justice Aedit Abdullah ruled that the previously served jail term should be treated as going towards the default sentence, and thus nothing remains to be served or paid. 

The judge said: “Any member of the public would be surprised, I think, that the three weeks previously served does not count, and that the appellant remains liable to either serve two weeks’ imprisonment, piled on top of the previous three weeks, or pay $8,000, or be subject to enforcement for that $8,000.

“The reduction of sentence imposed by the court in effect makes his punishment more severe: The appellant would have been better off had he lost his appeal.”

The prosecution, led by Senior Counsel Mohamed Faizal Mohamed Abdul Kadir, had argued that a default sentence is imposed not to punish the offender, but to prevent evasion of payment of the fine.

But the judge said anyone who has served a default sentence would attest that it was punishment.

“You are in prison. You are deprived of your liberty. You are not free,” he said.

The prosecution also argued that the Criminal Procedure Code (CPC) does not provide a mechanism for the backdating of a default term, and cited a Malaysian High Court case which held that a default sentence cannot be backdated.

Justice Abdullah was not persuaded, saying that the Malaysian case was concerned with remand rather than punishment.

He turned to a provision under the CPC which states that when the law does not provide for a certain procedure, “such procedure as the justice of the case may require” may be adopted.

He found that there was a gap in the law relating to the current case.

Source link

Most Popular


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More from Author

Read Now

USC football vs. ASU updates, analysis, score from Pac-12 Conference Week 4 college game

The Arizona State Sun Devils host the USC Trojans in a Week 4 Pac-12 college football game on Saturday night at Mountain America Stadium in Tempe.Arizona State (1-2) is coming off a 29-0 loss against Fresno State.USC (3-0) was off last week after beating Stanford in Week...

Australia making most of ‘massive opportunity’ at NHL Global Series — Melbourne | NHL.com

You could see NHL gear all over the city Saturday, from Queen Victoria Market to the Central Business District to Melbourne Park, where fans participated in activities at the NHL Global Fan Tour outside Rod Laver Arena. It was an interesting mix of expats and Aussies. Kyle Webb...

Before We All Leave WhatsApp Because of the Channels Feature

From the COLlive inbox: "Educators and parents are very concerned about the new Channels feature on WhatsApp, turning it into another social media platform. Simply getting everyone to leave WhatsApp may not be the ultimate solution to the concerns we face." Full Story By Mendel Educators...

Jung Kook Hints ‘3D’ Is Coming, Brings Out Latto & Performs ‘Still With You’ Live for the First Time at Global Citizen 2023

Rob Kim/Getty Images for Global Citizen A lot happened in a too-short amount of time when Jung Kook made his Global Citizen Festival solo debut as co-headliner on a rainy day in New York City Saturday (Sept. 23). The ARMY was in full force supporting the BTS...

No magic pill for living till 100, but there are nine lessons we can learn: Dan Buettner – Times of India

Dan Buettner has spent years researching Blue Zones, the five places in the world where people live the longest, healthiest lives. With his documentary on the secrets of longevity creating quite a buzz, he spoke to Sunday Times about what centenarians can teach usHave you uncovered...

Stunning $6.75m mansion has BELL BOARD inspired by Downton Abbey

A Texan mansion on the outskirts of Dallas features unique touches such as a servant bell board reminiscent of the one seen in Downton AbbeyThe five bedroom home, which sits on six-acres of land was built in 2017, and is set to enter to market for...

Suella Braverman, UK interior minister, to raise ‘unsustainable’ migration pressures during U.S. visit

Home Secretary Suella Braverman walks on Downing Street on the day of a cabinet meeting, in London, Britain September 5, 2023 REUTERS/Peter Nicholls/File Photo Acquire Licensing RightsLONDON, Sept 24 (Reuters) - British interior minister Suella Braverman will raise the "the unsustainable pressures" created by illegal...

UK’s Braverman Seeks US Support for ‘Blueprint’ on Migration

UK Home Secretary Suella Braverman will travel to Washington on Monday to meet with the heads of the Department of Justice and Homeland Security as she seeks support for the British government’s hardline anti-migration push.Braverman will meet Secretary of Homeland Security Alejandro Mayorkas and Attorney General...

College football scores, updates: Deion Sanders, Colorado blown out by Oregon

Week 4 brings the most loaded college football slate in recent memory with six ranked-on-ranked matchups and that doesn't even include a Florida State-Clemson game that had everyone on the edge of their seats.In one of the marquee games of the day, No. 10 Oregon absolutely...

Evil Geniuses Valorant roster reportedly stuck in “contract jail” despite pay cuts – Dexerto

Carver Fisher  ❘   Published: 2023-09-23T21:11:23  ❘   Updated: 2023-09-23T21:11:35 Evil Geniuses Valorant team was reported to be taking pay cuts if they wanted to stick with the organization despite winning Valorant Champions as the best team in the World. Not only that, the team is also...